How to compare two freight quotes from China line by line
Who is this guide for?
Two forwarders have priced the same shipment. One says $420 and the other says $610. Before you choose, find out where each price starts, where it ends and what will appear on a second invoice. Here is how to turn both offers into numbers you can compare.
Send both forwarders the same packing list
Give them the collection address, delivery postcode, cargo-ready date, description of the goods and any special handling needs. Include the number, outside dimensions and gross weight of the packed cartons. If the cartons travel on a pallet, send its loaded dimensions and weight. Include a delivery constraint such as a residential address or a warehouse that takes appointments. Before booking, check the packing list against the commercial invoice and confirm the final carton count.
Ask each forwarder to name the origin and destination terminals, route, service and delivery point. One offer that ends at a port and one that ends at your shop are answers to different questions. For shared-container freight, ask for the minimum charge and the unit they use to bill the shipment.
Compare who pays each line
Suppose both offers cover twelve cartons going from the same warehouse in China to your stockroom. Here is an illustrative comparison in US dollars. Duties and taxes are excluded from both offers and budgeted separately.
| Charge | Forwarder A | Forwarder B |
|---|---|---|
| Pickup, export handling and main transport | $420 | $490 |
| Destination handling | $150 | $65 |
| Broker’s service fee | $75 | $55 |
| Delivery to stockroom | $95 | Included |
| Comparable quoted total | $740 | $610 |
A’s opening figure was $190 lower than B’s headline total. Once the destination bills are included, B is $130 cheaper. If A says the destination agent will advise charges on arrival, put “unknown” against that line and ask for the agent’s written estimate. Entering zero makes the comparison meaningless.
Check the terms behind the total
Ask what happens if the factory misses the agreed cargo-ready date. Which sailing is the quote based on? Does the rate expire at booking, collection or departure? Ask for free storage time and the daily charge after it ends. Where cargo insurance is offered, get the insured amount, deductible and main exclusions. A lower quote can still work for you if you know which costs you are retaining.
For context, Drewry assessed a 40-foot container from Shanghai to Rotterdam at $3,504 on 12 November 2026, compared with $9,020 to New York. Both observations came from the same week. The destination makes a substantial difference even before asking who pays for local delivery. Neither number prices twelve cartons in a shared container. Drewry World Container Index, 12 November 2026.
A message you can send back
“Please revise your quote for collection at [address] and delivery to [postcode]. Show pickup, export handling, main freight, destination charges, brokerage and final delivery. For each line, state included, excluded or payable to another party. Please confirm the quote expiry, cargo cutoff, estimated delivery window and any charges that depend on a delay.”
Keep both replies with the packing list version they priced. If your factory adds two cartons, send the revision to both forwarders before you decide. For the choice of transport itself, read the sea and air freight guide.