Skip to content
Import guides

Commercial invoice vs packing list: how to check a shipment from China

By Daniel Ngissah

Who is this guide for? Your supplier has emailed two PDFs. The commercial invoice says 300 bags. The packing list says twelve cartons. Your forwarder wants a weight and a volume. You can answer all three questions, but first you need to know what’s inside each carton.

The commercial invoice records the sale: who sold what to whom, in what quantity, at what price and in which currency. The packing list describes the physical shipment: which packages are going, what each contains, how big they are and what they weigh. The two documents should tell the same story about the goods from different angles. Confirm destination-specific document requirements with your broker or forwarder. US International Trade Administration’s guide to commercial invoices and export packing lists.

Start with the references and the parties

Open the final invoice and the final packing list side by side. Check the invoice number, PO reference, shipment date or revision, seller, buyer and consignee. The consignee may be your fulfilment warehouse. A separate exporter may appear as shipper. Confirm those roles against your booking instructions and ask about any unexplained company name or delivery address.

Use the supplier’s original quote or pro forma invoice as a comparison. The final commercial invoice should describe the goods actually being shipped. If a second batch will follow, have the supplier identify the partial shipment and reconcile it against the open order. Forwarding the original 300-unit quote with a shipment of 250 is an easy way to give your broker the wrong starting figure.

Rebuild the shipment from its cartons

Here is an illustrative mixed-colour order. The invoice lists 200 natural bags and 100 navy bags. Both cost $4 each, so the goods subtotal is $1,200. The factory’s packing list gives the following measurements for loose cartons. Outside dimensions and weights are per packed carton.

Cartons and contentsOutside sizeNet / gross per cartonUnits
1–8, natural bags50 × 40 × 30 cm5 / 5.8 kg8 × 25 = 200
9–12, navy bags50 × 40 × 35 cm5 / 6 kg4 × 25 = 100

Count by SKU first. Eight natural cartons and four navy cartons give 300 bags in the colour split you bought. If the warehouse instead packed seven natural and five navy, you would still see 300 units on both PDFs. You would be short 25 natural bags and over by 25 navy bags. Total quantity alone would miss it.

Check weight next. In this example the goods weigh 12 × 5 = 60 kg net. Gross weight, including their cartons and packing, is (8 × 5.8) + (4 × 6) = 70.4 kg. Ask whether the factory weighed the finished cartons or simply copied a product catalogue weight. Your carrier needs the packed figures.

Calculate the volume in cubic metres (CBM). Convert centimetres to metres before multiplying. The first group takes 8 × 0.50 × 0.40 × 0.30 = 0.48 m³. The second takes 4 × 0.50 × 0.40 × 0.35 = 0.28 m³. Total loose-carton volume is 0.76 m³. If the cargo will travel on pallets, get the loaded pallet count, outside dimensions and gross weights. A forwarder pricing the palletised shipment needs those figures.

Check values on the invoice and marks on the cartons

  • Invoice. Compare SKU descriptions, quantities, unit prices, currency, extended totals, separately stated charges and the agreed delivery term with the accepted order. A deposit already paid reduces the balance due. Distinguish that balance from the full transaction amount and ask your broker how charges should be treated for customs valuation.
  • Packing list. Check carton numbering, contents by SKU, units per carton, dimensions and units of measurement, and net and gross weights. Ask for the breakdown of any mixed or partly filled carton. “12 boxes of accessories” gives the receiving warehouse no way to trace a shortage.
  • Booking. Send your forwarder the same revision supplied to your broker. Confirm the pickup address, package type, count and cargo-ready date. A quote based on 0.60 m³ needs reviewing if the packed shipment measures 0.76 m³. How to compare two freight quotes line by line.

What to send when the numbers disagree

Suppose the invoice is right, but a packing-list row says ten cartons of natural and two of navy. Ask the factory to physically check the carton marks and open a carton where necessary. Let the result determine whether the goods need repacking or a document needs correcting. Changing the spreadsheet to match the order could leave the wrong stock on the truck.

For PO [number], invoice [reference] shows 200 natural and 100 navy bags. Packing list [revision] gives a different split. Please confirm the actual carton numbers, quantity by colour and packed weights. Once checked, please issue the corrected document with a new revision and confirm which copy our forwarder should book against.

Before pickup, you should be able to give one answer in a single line: “12 loose cartons, 300 bags, 70.4 kg gross, 0.76 m³, invoice and packing-list revisions attached.” Keep those copies for receiving. If carton 10 is missing at delivery, you can identify its contents without reopening the price negotiation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *